Thursday, September 11, 2014

ETEC 561 Week 3 - Evaluation and Implementation


I searched the internet and found two other models, not discussed in the book. 
Lawrence Stenhouse’s research model was created in the 1970s and uses evaluation as part of curriculum development.  It features an ongoing cycle of curriculum adjustment based on formative evaluations.  This is considered a two person job in which the developer or teacher offers improvement ideas while the evaluator or student must determine the success of the learning.  This is a trial and error process, leading to continuous improvement through professional development and self-evaluation.  Students become responsible for their own learning and do not focus on objective-based curriculum.
Ralph Tyler’s objectives model is almost the complete opposite of Stenhouse’s model.  Tyler focused on planning and action in relation to a pre-selected set of objectives.  The methodology is not set but is determined by the standard determined by the objective.  In this method, focus is placed on formative evaluations.  In contrast to Stenhouse’s model evaluations focus only on lesson objectives and leaves no room for student involvement in evaluation of the lesson’s success.
I believe the purpose of all education (including curriculum development) should lead to mature, well-rounded learners.  Some skills are harder to evaluate than others.  A student’s ability to graph equations of lines is easily quantified, but their ability to make ethical decisions is harder to judge.  I feel responsible for helping students with both of these educational concerns.  I think instructional design evaluation should also address more obtuse goals, like values and problem-solving skills.  It would also be useful to know how much they learn is retained for a lifetime and how much is forgotten as soon as the class is finished.  How much of what they learn in your class is used for a lifetime?

If you work for a school district, you will no doubt be faced with the problem of being successful in the face of economic decline.  Money is always tight for school districts; budgets often get cut. Before being any type of training, I would choose to survey what technology is already being used (to determine what technology is available to work with) and what teachers already know (and what they do not know) so that I could evaluate what I have to work with and what I need to teach.  I would attempt to make the existing technology stretch as far as possible and encourage teachers would already do amazing things with it help train others in how they do things.  This would encourage others to mentor learning and teach new uses for technology using existing equipment.  I would choose to purchase new technology sparingly and only after being assured it will be fully utilized by the staff.  There is no reason to spend money on any materials that will not be used effectively.


Works Cited:
Hendricks, Cher C. "A Review of the Work of Lawrence Stenhouse: Questions, Ambiguities, and Possibilities." Teacher Research 12.1 (Fall 2002): 117-22. Eeranline.org. Web. 11 Sept. 2014. <http://www.eeraonline.org/journal/files/2002/JRE_2002_15_Hendricks.pdf>.

"EVOLUTION OF THE MODEL - Tyler Objective Curriculum Evaluation Model." EVOLUTION OF THE MODEL - Tyler Objective Curriculum Evaluation Model. N.p., n.d. Web. 11 Sept. 2014. <http://tylerobjectivemodel.weebly.com/evolution-of-the-model.html>.

5 comments:

  1. Hello Hope,

    I like the way you went outside of the book to find other models, I was wondering about that myself, but I thought I had better show that I read each and every page. It makes for a better post also to find the vast differences in the models. The book models just vary a bit in certain aspects compared to your examples.

    I too work in a school district with very limited funds. My classroom is virtually paperless because of supply and demand. We did not have any paper but I still had to teach the learners. I am still trying to get funding for flash drives for my learners. Your example of facilitating is what I live on a daily.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have never seen a school employee say their district was rolling in cash. I think it is just the nature of school funding and student needs that we are constantly in need of more funds.
      I am fortunate to teach mostly computer classes and I am able to greatly reduce my paper use by utilizing email, Google Docs and Schoology. (I love Schoology, btw). My science class still uses paper from time to time, but I am trying to cut it back as much as possible. Every penny counts.

      Delete
  2. Hi Hope,
    Excellent Blog! Nice find on Ralph Tyler. I had to research him after reading your blog. He seems to be one of the preeminent educational evaluators of our time. I am not an educator as of yet, so forgive me when I ask this. When you say “I think instructional design evaluation should also address more obtuse goals, like values and problem-solving skills”, isn’t values something that should be instilled by a child’s parents. I would think that morale values and fortitude is something that is part of parenting (but that’s just me).
    On purchasing technology, technology these days is advancing at an exponential rate. If we upgrade (purchase) technology too sparingly, an educator (and students) could easily find themselves behind the curve. In my present position, we tend to spend more on technology in the classroom than we do in the office. At one point (say 7-10 years ago), many institutions skimped on technology investments. Before anyone realized the implications, we as a nation had fallen behind the rest of the world on education, particularly in technology. So, yes, I believe in budgeting for technology and I believe that we as educators (which I will someday be) need to keep pace with technology for our children sake. But that’s just my two cents. Keep or Toss.. Great Blog! Nice Work!

    David

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you, David. Parents should definitely be instilling moral values and fortitude in to their children. But teachers must also encourage it. Some kids spend more time with their teachers than with their parents. Since kids replicate what they see, we must be moral leaders in their lives too. This is important enough to the state of Texas that they include it in the Code of Ethics:
      (J) Standard 1.10. The educator shall be of good moral character and be worthy to instruct or supervise the youth of this state.
      In a perfect world, kids would come to teachers with a positive attitude, a love of learning and an honest heart, but the truth is a lot kids do not get that from home.

      I agree with you on technology. I teach technology in my classroom and with the new Endorsement plans they are encouraging certifications in Microsoft products like Word and Excel. The problem is our district is still using Office 2003. If I certify a freshman in 2015 in Office 2003 and they do not use it until they graduate in 2019, has the certification really benefitted the student? Will anyone still be using 2003 in 2019? Districts have to weigh the benefit to students against the cost. I am so glad that is not my decision to make.
      Thanks for posting!

      Delete
  3. Hi Hope, once again, I enjoyed reading your blog. I agree that there needs to be different forms of evaluation. I liked that you included forms based on communication and self assessment and also assessment and data. I think both are very necessary in helping students to receive a well rounded education. I also like that you addressed the obtuse goals that help students to be successful in the real world. I also think that you were wise to consider how you could use technology that you already have. I think teachers are much more willing to listen and try something if it affects their situation immediately. If they had to go out and gather new technology I think they are less likely to buy in.

    ReplyDelete